Posted 01/27/2026
Job Number: 15320

Senior Commercial Auto Underwriter

Jericho, NY Hybrid

Industry:  Insurance

Job Category: Insurance

Job Type:  Direct Hire

Salary:  $90,000 - $100,000/Annually

Share This Job

Job Description

Position Title: Senior Commercial Auto Underwriter

The Senior Commercial Auto Underwriter will play a critical role in managing and executing underwriting functions within a dynamic insurance environment. This position involves evaluating various commercial auto risks, particularly in sectors such as trucking, garages, and towing. The underwriter will be responsible for pricing and negotiating terms, ensuring compliance with guidelines, and fostering strong relationships with brokers and agents. The ideal candidate will have extensive experience in underwriting and a solid understanding of the commercial auto insurance landscape. This role demands strong analytical skills and the ability to mentor junior staff while adapting to a rapidly growing company culture. The position operates in a hybrid work environment, providing flexibility and opportunities for professional growth.

Salary Range: $90,000 – $100,000 / Year DOE

Senior Commercial Auto Underwriter Responsibilities:

  • Review and analyze new and renewal submissions
  • Price accounts using internal tools and prepare quotes and binders
  • Set coverage terms, conditions, and exclusions based on each risk
  • Negotiate pricing and terms with brokers and agents
  • Evaluate loss history, financials, exposures, and profitability
  • Monitor existing accounts and recommend adjustments as needed
  • Refer complex risks to management when outside authority
  • Maintain accurate underwriting files and documentation
  • Handle endorsements and ensure compliance with guidelines
  • Build and maintain strong broker and agency relationships
  • Participate in virtual and in-person marketing visits
  • Serve as a technical resource to the team
  • Assist with mentoring and training junior staff
  • Support business growth and retention strategies
  • Support special projects and business initiatives

Senior Commercial Auto Underwriter Requirements:

  • 8+ years of underwriting experience
  • High school diploma
  • Proficiency in Word and Outlook
  • Experience in commercial auto insurance, specifically in trucking, garage, and towing
  • Bachelor’s degree preferred
  • Insurance certifications/designations preferred
  • Experience writing in multiple states preferred
  • Prior experience with insurance companies and larger MGAs preferred
  • E&S underwriting experience preferred

Benefits:

  • Medical coverage with 50% covered for the employee through United Healthcare / Oxford Liberty, eligible after 3 months
  • 401K
  • Generous PTO
  • Friendly and supportive company culture in a small team
  • Hybrid work environment

If you are a Senior Commercial Auto Underwriter looking to take the next step in your career, apply now! #LI-SB1

Job ID: a0CUm00003extKwMAI

Apply For This Position

Related Jobs

About Us

At Boutique Recruiting, we specialize in personalized, connection-driven placements, empowering candidates to achieve their goals. Committed to bold, impactful solutions, we fill roles of all types—full-time, part-time, and more—ensuring success for clients, candidates, and employees alike.

Job Details About Us Image

5-Star Reviews From Our Candidates